Capital Athletic Conference Honors | ||
| Year | Name | Honor |
| 2003 | Gary Dunda | Coach of the Year |
All-Capital Athletic Conference Selections | ||
| Year | Name (Pos) | Team |
| 1991 | Percy Moore (F) | First |
| 1991 | Steve Montgomery (F) | Second |
| 1991 | Pat Prendergast (M) | Second |
| 1991 | Purnell Saunders (B) | Second |
| 1992 | Percy Moore (F) | First |
| 1992 | Steve Montgomery (F) | Second |
| 1992 | Seth Bachman (M) | Second |
| 1992 | Pat Prendergast (M) | Second |
| 1992 | Ian Dillner (B) | Second |
| 1992 | Brian Garrahy (G) | Second |
| 1993 | Percy Moore (F) | First |
| 1993 | David Di Angelo (M) | Second |
| 1993 | Pat Prendergast (M) | Second |
| 1993 | Todd Covert (B) | Second |
| 1993 | Ian Dillner (B) | Second |
| 1994 | Percy Moore (F) | First |
| 1994 | Seth Bachman (M) | Second |
| 1994 | Pat Prendergast (M) | Second |
| 1994 | Ian Dillner (B) | Second |
| 1995 | Radcliffe Roye (F) | First |
| 1995 | Jim St. Jean (B) | First |
| 1995 | Ian Dillner (B) | Second |
| 1996 | Chris Walton (F) | First |
| 1996 | Brian Fortman (M) | Second |
| 1996 | David St. Jean (B) | Second |
| 1997 | Jeff Lowe (G) | First |
| 1997 | David St. Jean (M) | Second |
| 1998 | Jeff Lowe (G) | First |
| 1998 | Billy Layton (FB) | Second |
| 1998 | Nate Densford (F) | Second |
| 1999 | Adam Hack (FB) | Second |
| 2000 | Chuck Combs (FB) | Second |
| 2001 | Logan Herring (FB) | First |
| 2002 | Logan Herring (FB) | First |
| 2002 | Rajan Pragani (M) | Second |
| 2003 | Logan Herring (M) | Second |
| 2003 | Nick Kiss (F) | Second |
| 2003 | Tom Feuerstein (G) | Second |
| 2004 | Brian Concklin (D) | Second |
| 2004 | Adam Wrede (F) | Second |
| 2004 | Kevin Bartruff (M) | Second |
| 2004 | Eddie Emokpae (F) | Second |
| 2005 | Kevin Bartruff (M) | Second |
| 2005 | Gary Decker (D) | Second |
| 2006 | Gary Decker (M) | First |
| 2006 | Eddie Emokpae (F) | Second |
All-Landmark Conference Selections | ||
| Year | Name (Pos) | Team |
| 2007 | Galen Guindon (M) | Second |
| 2008 | Tim McMullen (D) | Second |