Name |
Sport(s) |
Year |
Team |
| Rory Averett | Men's Lacrosse | 2010-11 2011-12 |
First team First team |
| Lizzie Barminski | Field Hockey | 2015-16 | Second Team |
| Amanda Bercovici | Women's Tennis | 2013-14 | First team |
| Kyle Boncaro | Men's Lacrosse | 2011-12 | First team (Captain) |
| Amory Brandt | Equestrian | 2010-11 2011-12 |
First team Second team |
| Briana Bull | Women's Basketball | 2016-17 | First Team |
| Joey Caracappa | Men's Tennis |
2014-15 2015-16 |
First Team First Team |
| Anna Carmichael | Equestrian | 2013-14 | Second team |
| Bryce Carson | Men's Lacrosse | 2012-13 | First team |
| Ogemdi Chukwu | Track & Field | 2016-17 | Second Team |
| Katherine Currier | Women's Cross Country and Indoor & Outdoor Track & Field |
2011-12 |
Second team First team |
| Sam Davis | Men's Swimming | 2014-15 | First Team |
| Owen Demmerly | Men's Tennis | 2015-16 | Second Team |
| Justin Dunn | Men's Lacrosse | 2010-11 | First team |
| Joey Fink | Equestrian |
2012-13 2014-15 |
Second team First Team (Captain) |
| Andrew Foster | Men's Lacrosse | 2013-14 | Second team |
| Jojo Franklin | Women's Lacrosse |
2014-15 2015-16 |
Second Team Second Team |
| Midori Fujitani | Men's Tennis | 2016-17 | Second Team |
| Michael Herman | Men's Tennis | 2016-17 | Second Team |
| Jack Hodges | Men's Tennis |
2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 |
Second Team First Team First Team |
| Seth Hoesman | Men's Tennis |
2012-13 2014-15 2015-16 |
Second team Second Team First Team |
| Sharnell Huff | Women's Basketball | 2013-14 | Second team |
| Cary Hundley | Equestrian |
2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 |
First Team (Co-Captain) First Team (Team Captain) First Team (Team Captain) |
| Pierce Ingram | Men's Lacrosse | 2013-14 | First team |
| Addie Jabin | Equestrian | 2012-13 | Second team |
| Jaclyn Kellon | Women's Indoor & Outdoor Track & Field | 2010-11 2012-13 |
First team First team (captain) |
| Hannah Khin | Women's Lacrosse | 2012-13 | Second team |
| Steph Lee | Men's Golf | 2017-18 | First Team |
| Clea Lerner | Equestrian | 2016-17 | First Team |
| Ariel Lin | Women's Tennis | 2012-13 | First team |
| Sarah Lummis | Equestrian |
2014-15 2015-16 |
Second Team Second Team |
| Matt Lynch | Men's Lacrosse | 2010-11 2011-12 |
First team (Captain) First team |
| Meaghan Lee | Women's Tennis | 2010-11 | Second team |
| Laura Malone | Equestrian | 2014-15 | Second Team |
| Matt Messerle | Men's Lacrosse | 2017-18 | Second Team |
| Roberto Mikse | Men's Golf | 2017-18 | First Team |
| Connor Mishaw | Men's Lacrosse |
2011-12 |
Second team First team |
| Kelsey Myette | Women's Cross Country | 2010-11 | Second team |
| Joey Negreann | Men's Cross Country and Indoor & Outdoor Track & Field | 2010-11 2011-12 |
Second team Second team |
| Tetsuya Ota | Men's Tennis | 2017-18 | First Team |
| Christina Pevey | Women's Golf | 2017-18 | Second Team |
| Destiny Phillips | Women's Indoor & Outdoor Track & Field | 2011-12 | First team |
| Drew Phillips | Men's Soccer | 2016-17 | First Team |
| Karli Postel | Equestrian | 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 |
Second team First team First team |
| Sisley Pumilia | Women's Soccer | 2010-11 | Second team |
| Lindsey Puopolo | Women's Soccer | 2012-13 | Second team |
| Erin Reifsnyder | Women's Lacrosse | 2013-14 | Second team |
| Colin Richter |
Men's Swimming |
2014-15 | Second Team |
| Morgan Richter | Men's Swimming |
2013-14 2015-16 |
First team First Team (Co-Captain) |
| Sarah Shklanko | Field Hockey |
2016-17 2017-18 |
Second Team Second Team |
| Kamillah Smith | Track & Field | 2015-16 | First Team |
| Emmie Starchvick | Women's Golf | 2017-18 | Second Team |
| Lexi Stewart | Track & Field | 2016-17 | First Team |
| Paul Taylor | Men's Lacrosse | 2011-12 | Second team |
| Brandon Wiener | Men's Soccer | 2014-15 | First Team |
| Matt Woodson | Men's Lacrosse | 2017-18 | Second Team |
