All-Landmark Conference
| Year | Name | Honor |
| 2011 | Trae Lindsay | Second |
| 2014 | Julian Livingston | Second |
| 2016 | Kevin Miles | Second |
| 2017 | Chris Outing | Second |
| 2018 | Jacob Smith | Rookie of the Year |
| 2024 | Liech Kong | Rookie of the Year, Honorable Mention |
| 2024 | Jacob Morgan | Honorable Mention |
All-Capital Athletic Conference
| Year | Name | Honor |
| 1992 | David Clark | First |
| 1993 | Predrag Durkovic | Second |
| 1993 | Gerard Garlic | Second |
| 1993 | David Clark | First |
| 1994 | Predrag Durkovic | Second |
| 1994 | David Clark | First |
| 1995 | Chad Beeten | Second |
| 1995 | Predrag Durkovic | First |
| 1996 | Tavar Witherspoon | Second |
| 1996 | Predrag Durkovic | First |
| 1997 | Tavar Witherspoon | Second |
| 1997 | Bakari Ward | First |
| 1998 | Mike Doyle | Second |
| 1998 | Bakari Ward | First |
| 2002 | Thabo Letsebe | First |
| 2003 | Garrett Smith | Second |
| 2003 | Pierre Jones | Second |
| 2004 | Trevor Quinn | Second |
| 2004 | Garrett Smith | First |
| 2005 | Jonathan Garritt | Second |